Galvanized vs. Black Hollow Iron Comparison: Which is More Durable?

Hollow iron is an important material in the construction world, especially for ceiling frames, canopies, fences, and building partitions. The two most commonly used types are galvanized hollow iron and black hollow iron. Although they look similar, they have different characteristics and durability.

To ensure you choose the right one for your project, here's a complete comparison of galvanized hollow iron and black hollow iron.

1. Rust Resistance
Galvanized Hollow Iron

• Has a zinc coating that protects against corrosion.
• It is suitable for damp or weather-exposed areas.
• It has high rust resistance, even without additional painting.

Black Hollow Iron

• Does not have a protective coating.
• Rusts easily if exposed to water or humid air.
• Requires additional coating such as anti-rust primer.

Conclusion:

• Galvanized hollow iron is far superior in corrosion resistance.

2. Structural Strength

• Galvanized Hollow Iron
• Strength depends on the thickness and quality of the galvanizing.
• Suitable for lightweight roof frames, canopies, fences, and ceilings.

Black Hollow Iron

• Has a higher density and is mechanically stronger.
• Widely used for heavy structures and frames that require high stability.

Conclusion:

• In terms of pure strength, black hollow iron is sturdier, but the difference depends on the specifications.

3. Applications
Galvanized Hollow Iron
Ideal for:

• Outdoor canopies
• Ceiling frames
• Minimalist fences
• Shelves and partitions
• Building facades
• Black Hollow Iron

Ideal for:

• Heavy structural frames
• Iron doors and windows
• Sturdy fence frames
• Indoor construction
• Industrial furniture

4. Lifespan

• Galvanized: Can last up to 10–20 years depending on the quality of the coating and environmental conditions.
• Black hollow iron: Has a shorter lifespan if not properly coated with anti-rust paint.

5. Maintenance

• Galvanized: Minimal maintenance; simply clean regularly.
• Black iron: Requires periodic repainting to prevent rust.

6. Price

• Galvanized hollow steel is generally more expensive due to the zinc coating process.
• Black hollow steel is more economical, suitable for projects with a limited budget.

Final Conclusion: Which is More Durable?
If corrosion resistance and longevity are the primary focus, then galvanized hollow steel is the best choice.
However, if you require higher structural strength for indoor applications, black hollow steel can be an alternative, provided it is protected with anti-rust paint.

Need Galvanized or Black Hollow Steel for Your Project?
PT Intisumber Bajasakti (ISBS) provides a complete range of high-quality hollow steel products that meet industry standards.

📞 Phone: 021-66675999
🌐 Website: intisumberbajasakti.com
✉️ Email: info@intisumberbajasakti.com

Back to List